New Orleans / About / How We Work

How we work.

We rank New Orleans restaurants on food, consistency, and value, the same way across a grand Creole dining room and a Mid-City po-boy counter.

9.9/10

The Insider Score Exceptional · Calibrated to New Orleans · Rebuilt weekly · Never for sale

The Insider Score

Every restaurant we cover earns an Insider Score: a single number from 0 to 10, calibrated to this city, rebuilt every week, and never for sale. It is not a raw average of other sites' stars. It is our own trust-weighted, momentum-adjusted, editor-confirmed read of the full review record. It weighs three things.

01Track record

How highly a kitchen rates, across how many diners, over how long. A 4.9 built on three thousand reviews counts for far more than a 5.0 built on thirty.

02Consistency

Whether recent diners still agree with the long-term verdict. A room that holds its standard outranks one coasting on old goodwill.

03Distinction

What a kitchen does that its category does not. The editorial pass that separates a very good taco shop from the one worth crossing town for. This layer is human, and never for sale.

The data

The inputs are the aggregate review record: ratings, review counts, hours, and operating status from Yelp, Google, and TripAdvisor, each used under its licensed terms. This is data journalism. We read what thousands of diners report over time, not one critic's single meal. No signal we use in a live ranking is more than 48 hours old.

A machine layer finds and scores candidates. A human layer confirms them and writes the editorial. Nothing on this site publishes without both passes.

The math

Trust-weighted rating

The rating is the main input, weighted by how much evidence stands behind it. A five-star room with thirty reviews gets pulled toward the city's average; a 4.9 with three thousand reviews holds its ground. It is the same Bayesian weighting IMDb uses for its Top 250: trust a rating in proportion to the sample size it is built on.

Momentum

Among rooms with similarly trusted ratings, the one with more sustained recent traffic edges ahead. It is a tiebreaker, not the main driver. A 4.5 with twelve thousand reviews cannot leapfrog a 4.9 with three thousand, but it can hold its own in the top ten.

The result is a list of restaurants that have both the rating to back it up and enough sample size to prove the rating is real, not a fluke.

The scale

Insider Scores are calibrated per city. The highest-ranked room in New Orleans sets the top of the scale at 9.9, and everything below scales to that anchor. The three factors and their weights are identical across every city in the network; only the local anchor moves.

We do this because every city's dining scene has its own ceiling. Forcing one global scale would either flatten smaller markets into the sixes and sevens or inflate the biggest ones until every city looked the same. Per-city calibration tells the truer story: this is the best room in this town, ranked against the rooms it actually competes with. A 9.9 in New Orleans is the best New Orleans has. It is not a claim about any other city.

What we don't do

No auto-publishing.

Every list and guide is read by an editor before it goes live. The algorithm proposes; the desk decides.

Corrections

Data ages. Restaurants close, change chefs, move rooms. If you spot an error, stale hours, a closed room, a factual mistake in a guide, email the desk and we will fix it. Substantive corrections are logged in the open: the Updated date on the guide changes, and the entry is revised. We do not silently edit published work.

The desk

Algorithms surface the candidates. Editors decide what earns a place, and in what order. Here is who reads the lists.

Beau Thibodeaux

Food Editor

Beau Thibodeaux covers the New Orleans canon for Top of New Orleans: the dressed po-boy, gumbo, red beans and rice, jambalaya, barbecue shrimp, muffuletta, char-grilled oysters, and the Creole soul-food table. A New Orleans native who works from the public review record.

Celeste Marchand

Chief Critic

Celeste Marchand is Top of New Orleans's chief critic, covering the grand-dame Creole institutions, the modern fine-dining rooms, and Uptown, the Garden District, and Magazine Street brunch. Analysis is built from the public review record, not press dinners.

Remy Boudreaux

Neighborhoods Editor

Remy Boudreaux covers New Orleans's neighborhoods for Top of New Orleans: Marigny, Bywater, Mid-City, and Treme, the dive bars and breweries, the gastropubs, and the independents that anchor a corner.

Marco Herrera

Latino & Global Editor

Marco Herrera covers the Latino and global table for Top of New Orleans: Honduran baleadas, Salvadoran pupusas, the West Bank and Kenner taquerias, and the Caribbean and Cuban rooms. A West Bank native who works from the public review record.

Linh Tran

Vietnamese & East Editor

Linh Tran covers the Vietnamese and East Asian table for Top of New Orleans: New Orleans East and West Bank pho and banh mi, Dong Phuong, and the Chinese, Thai, Korean, and Japanese rooms across the metro.

Unsigned analysis runs under a shared byline, the Top Rated Editorial Team. Signed work carries the editor's name.

Five rooms, every Friday.

The new opening, the sleeper the score just flagged, and the one room worth booking this week. Free.