Top of New Orleans

New Orleans / Guides / Restaurants in Uptown
The Guide · Restaurants in Uptown

Best Restaurants in Uptown (2026)

Best Restaurants in Uptown: 1. Superior Seafood & Oyster Bar · 2. BEARCAT CAFE UPTOWN · 3. The High Hat Cafe · 4. Mahony's Po-boys · 5. New Orleans Hamburger & Seafood Co. Addresses, prices and what to order.

11rooms ranked
7.1top score
2on the List
June 2026last updated
Remy Boudreaux
By Remy Boudreaux Neighborhoods Editor · Scores from Issue № 137 · How the score is built
Best Restaurants in Uptown (2026)

Uptown runs from the edge of the Garden District out to the Carrollton bend, and Magazine Street alone is reason enough to leave the Quarter behind. The neighborhood rooms here range from a corner po-boy shop to Alon Shaya's Israeli kitchen, and the everyday lunch stops are as serious as the dinner destinations. This guide covers eleven of the best, ranked by Insider Score.

№ 01

Superior Seafood & Oyster Bar

5.7Solid
Superior Seafood & Oyster Bar Photo via Yelp

The happy-hour oyster special here is the honest kind: properly sized, properly cold, properly shucked. The seafood platter and grilled fish hold up on the full menu, and the room runs at a pace that suits anyone who has spent a long afternoon on the streetcar or walking the Garden District. Counter to the name, this is a full sit-down room, family-friendly and straightforward about what it is.

Scored from the full review record
№ 02

BEARCAT CAFE UPTOWN

7.1Great
BEARCAT CAFE UPTOWN Photo via Yelp

The tofu scramble at Bearcat is the kind of dish that makes the vegan-breakfast case without argument. The breakfast plate of the day rotates and holds its own, and the room operates clean and calm, which is rare for a brunch spot drawing the kind of attention this one does. People cross town for this meal, and the report back is consistently that it was the right call.

Scored from the full review record
№ 03

The High Hat Cafe

5.8Solid
The High Hat Cafe Photo via Yelp

The High Hat is a proper Uptown lunch room. Order the gumbo, then the fried oyster po-boy on Leidenheimer-style French bread, dressed. The fresh ginger ale at four dollars is not an afterthought. Service runs warm and attentive, and the room has the feel of a place that has been doing this long enough to stop trying too hard. Dinner works too, but the midday meal is the move.

Scored from the full review record
№ 04

Mahony's Po-boys

4.2Notable
Mahony's Po-boys Photo via Yelp

Mahony's is the Magazine Street po-boy stop that locals point visitors toward when they want the real thing. The shrimp po-boy comes on bread that holds up, with shrimp fried right. The Peacemaker, the classic half-oyster half-shrimp combination, is the order for first-timers. A Cubano rounds out the menu for anyone who wants something outside the Creole lane. Late-night hours make it useful in ways most po-boy shops are not.

What to orderShrimp Po-boy, Peacemaker, Cubano
Scored from the full review record
№ 05

New Orleans Hamburger & Seafood Co

3.7Notable
New Orleans Hamburger & Seafood Co Photo via Yelp

Counter-service seafood done at volume and done well. The fried shrimp basket is the anchor, and the seafood po-boy moves fast. Order at the counter, find a seat, and the food arrives without ceremony. The room is casual and family-friendly, the cocktail list adds some range, and the pace is quick enough that the line, when there is one, moves.

Scored from the full review record
№ 06

The Company Burger

5.2Solid
The Company Burger Photo via Yelp

The Company Burger's cheeseburger single smash is flat, seared hard, and not fussy about it. The onion rings and sweet potato fries are the right supporting cast. The mayo bar is a genuine differentiator: a selection of house-made options that turns a burger run into something worth lingering over. The room runs busy but prompt, and the staff keeps pace. This is Uptown's corner burger joint, and it earns the title.

Scored from the full review record
№ 07

Saba

6.1Solid
Saba Photo via Yelp

Alon Shaya's Israeli kitchen on Magazine Street is one of the few New Orleans rooms doing serious Mediterranean work. The lutenitsa is light and sharp, the hummus is the foundational order, and the shakshuka anchors the savory side. The room runs busy at lunch, but the floor manages it. Shaya holds a James Beard Award, and the kitchen reflects that pedigree without making the room feel out of reach.

What to orderLutenitsa, hummus, falafel
Scored from the full review record
№ 08

Guy's Po-Boys

6.3Solid
Guy's Po-Boys Photo via Yelp

Guy's is a small Uptown room with a short menu and no ambiguity about what it is. The roast beef po-boy, the shrimp, and the fried oyster are the three orders that matter. The space is tight, walk-in-friendly, and family-manageable. Locals bring visitors here after the Audubon Zoo or a Magazine Street afternoon. The bread is right, the fillings are right, and the price stays reasonable.

Scored from the full review record
№ 09

St James Cheese Company

6.3Solid
St James Cheese Company Photo via Yelp

St. James Cheese Company runs a real cheesemonger operation: staff who know the counter, a selection that includes serious goat cheeses and a charcuterie program worth building a meal around. The sandwiches are made with the same care as the retail side. Outdoor seating and a by-the-glass wine list make it easy to turn a cheese-shop stop into a proper sit-down. The neighborhood room equivalent of a wine bar, without the pretense.

Scored from the full review record
№ 10

Baru Bistro & Tapas

5.7Solid
Baru Bistro & Tapas Photo via Yelp

Baru runs a Tuesday tapas deal, three plates for twenty-one dollars, that makes the Latin American small-plates format genuinely affordable. The steak skewers are the standout order. The margaritas during happy hour are the reason the bar fills early. The room suits a date or a small group, and the drink specials give it a useful weekday role that dinner-only spots on this block can't match.

Scored from the full review record
№ 11

Midway Pizza

5.1Solid
Midway Pizza Photo via Yelp

Midway is the Uptown pizza room for a casual Monday afternoon or a weekday happy hour. Big windows, an open layout, and a bar that runs decent specials give it a neighborhood-gathering-place feel. The pizza is the main event; bar appetizers fill out the menu. Service at the bar is attentive. The kitchen keeps things straightforward, and the room does not try to be more than a solid neighborhood pizza joint.

Scored from the full review record

Frequently asked

What are the best restaurants near me in Uptown New Orleans?
The eleven restaurants in this guide cover the Uptown corridor from the Garden District edge to Carrollton. Mahony's and Guy's handle po-boys on Magazine Street, Saba brings serious Israeli-Mediterranean cooking, and Bearcat Cafe is the vegan brunch destination the neighborhood did not expect to need. Each entry is ranked by Insider Score, which is calculated from verified customer feedback. No restaurant pays to be listed.
How does the Insider Score work?
The Insider Score is a calculated ranking drawn from verified customer feedback across the review record. It weights consistency, dish quality, and service patterns. No restaurant pays to appear in this guide or to influence its score.
Is Uptown worth eating in, or should I stay in the French Quarter?
Uptown is where a significant share of the serious everyday eating happens. Magazine Street runs a dense stretch of neighborhood rooms, from po-boy counters to Alon Shaya's James Beard-recognized kitchen at Saba. The French Quarter has real institutions, but Uptown has the corner joints and the local lunch spots that the Quarter tourist corridor does not.
Which Uptown restaurants are good for a casual lunch?
The High Hat Cafe is the reliable sit-down comfort-food room for lunch, with gumbo and a fried oyster po-boy as the anchors. Mahony's handles the po-boy stop with later hours. Guy's is the right call for a quick, honest roast beef or shrimp po-boy. All three are ranked by Insider Score, and none pay for placement.
ƒ

The data first, then the verdict

We start with the review record, not a press release. Every room here is a real kitchen with a strong rating across a meaningful number of reviews, ranked on our 10-point Insider Score. We weight consistency over time and the rooms locals return to, not the ones tourists pass through once. The list updates as the data does. How we work →

Remy Boudreaux
Remy Boudreaux
Neighborhoods Editor

Remy Boudreaux covers New Orleans's neighborhoods for Top of New Orleans: Marigny, Bywater, Mid-City, and Treme, the dive bars and breweries, the gastropubs, and the independents that anchor a corner.

Five rooms, every Friday.

The new opening, the sleeper the score just flagged, and the one room worth booking this week. Free.